Tagged: Middle Path
Pages with this tag
Anālayo - The Chinese Parallels to the Dhammacakkappavattana-sutta (2) (2012)
1This academic paper analyzes Chinese parallels to the Dhammacakkappavattana-sutta, the Buddha's first sermon, to understand the text's development. By comparing versions from the Ekottarika-āgama, Mahīśāsaka Vinaya, and Dharmaguptaka Vinaya, the author argues that variations point to a history of oral transmission and gradual elaboration. The existence of both a short version focusing on the two extremes and a longer one including the Four Noble Truths within the same collection suggests the former is an extract, not evidence that the truths were a later addition. The analysis notes that features like the qualifier "noble" for the truths, elaborate miracles like earthquakes, and the full exposition of the "three turnings and twelve modes" may be later developments, while core elements like the celestial acclamations are consistently present. The text also explores the sermon's internal logic, framing the Four Noble Truths as a pragmatic medical diagnosis (disease, cause, cure, treatment), clarifying *duhkha* as "unsatisfactory" rather than just "suffering," and emphasizing that the "turning of the wheel" is complete only when an audience member achieves realization.
Krishan - Buddhism and Belief in Ātman (1984)
2The central question in Buddhism regarding a permanent soul, or *ātman*, presents a significant dilemma - the doctrine of *anattā* (no-soul) appears to contradict the belief in karma and rebirth, as it leaves no entity to bear the consequences of actions. The Buddha himself rejected the extreme views of both an eternal, unchanging soul and complete annihilation after death, instead advocating a middle path. Various Buddhist schools attempted to resolve this by proposing concepts that function like a soul without being one, such as a "rebirth-linking consciousness" (*patisandhi viññāna*), an "intermediate existence" (*antarābhava*), or an inexpressible "person" (*pudgala*). The author argues that the doctrine of *anattā* is primarily a rejection of the ego and the notions of "I" and "mine," which are the root of suffering, rather than a denial of a conscious principle. This is supported by the development of concepts like the "store-consciousness" (*ālaya-vijñāna*) and post-mortem rituals in Buddhist cultures, which imply belief in a transmigrating entity. Ultimately, Buddhism seems to deny a static, eternal soul but affirms a dynamic, impermanent yet continuous empirical self that carries karma and memory, likened to a river's current, which is only extinguished upon attaining *nirvāṇa*.