Tagged: Sangha
Pages with this tag
Seeger - The Bhikkhunī-ordination controversy in Thailand (2006)
1The ordination of Chatsumarn Kabilsingh as Bhikkhunī Dhammanandā has sparked a significant controversy within Thai Theravāda Buddhism regarding the revival of the extinct female monastic lineage. Proponents argue for the legitimacy of female ordination by citing the validity of descendant lineages like the Dharmaguptaka, interpreting the Buddha's teachings as prioritizing spiritual potential over social convention, appealing to the Thai constitution's principles of gender equality and religious freedom, and critiquing the historical decision to "freeze" the monastic code (*Vinaya*). Conversely, traditionalists, including the Thai *saṅgha* and the influential monk Phra Payutto, maintain that a valid ordination is impossible because the *Vinaya* requires a dual ceremony involving an unbroken line of Theravāda nuns, which no longer exists. They argue that altering the canon or using a different lineage (*nānāsaṃvāsa*) would violate sacred texts and destroy the consensus essential for preserving the tradition's integrity. Amid this debate, some prominent female practitioners (*maechis*) and laywomen argue that a *bhikkhunī* order is unnecessary for spiritual practice and that women should focus on self-development within existing structures, while others propose para-monastic alternatives to accommodate modern needs without conflicting with canonical authority.
Gombrich, Richard F. - Theravāda Buddhism (2006)
2Richard Gombrich's *Theravāda Buddhism* provides a social history of this conservative branch of Buddhism, which originated with the Buddha's teachings in 5th-century BCE India on achieving salvation (*nibbāna*) from suffering through a "Middle Way" of morality, meditation, and wisdom. Central to this path was the redefinition of *kamma* as intention and the denial of an eternal soul (*anattā*), doctrines preserved and spread by a monastic Order (the Sangha) governed by a detailed disciplinary code (*vinaya*). With the patronage of Emperor Asoka, Theravāda was established in Sri Lanka around 250 BCE, where it became fused with Sinhalese national identity and developed a devotional culture of pilgrimage and relic worship, while the Sangha adapted to its role as a land-owning elite, undergoing cycles of decline and revival. The 19th century brought a major transformation with the rise of "Protestant Buddhism," a lay-led movement reacting to Christian missionaries and colonial rule, which reinterpreted Buddhism as a rational, scientific philosophy and promoted lay activism. In the contemporary era, this legacy has been shaped by civil war and globalization, fostering a more intense nationalism and new forms of lay religiosity, from ecstatic god-worship to the re-establishment of the nuns' order, presenting new challenges and adaptations for the ancient tradition.
Gombrich - What the Buddha Thought (2009)
3In *What the Buddha Thought*, Richard Gombrich argues that the Buddha was a brilliant and original thinker whose coherent system of thought can only be understood by placing it in its historical context as a pragmatic debate with and reaction to contemporary Brahminical and Jain ideas. Gombrich posits that the Buddha was not an essentialist philosopher but a practical teacher focused on how things function, redefining concepts like *kamma* from ritual action to ethical intention and clarifying "no-self" as the absence of an *unchanging* essence. A central thesis is that subsequent generations, failing to grasp the Buddha's use of metaphor, irony, and context-dependent arguments, took his teachings literally, thereby creating new scholastic doctrines—such as misinterpreting the *brahma-vihāras* as a path to heaven rather than nirvana. This process of misinterpretation, Gombrich contends, explains many apparent inconsistencies in the Pali Canon, which he establishes as the key evidence for understanding how the Buddha used fire as a central metaphor for non-random process and satirized Vedic cosmogony in the Chain of Dependent Origination.